Assignment 204: "Ecocriticism in Literature: Evolution, Key Concepts, and Emerging Directions"

"Ecocriticism in Literature: Evolution, Key Concepts, and Emerging Directions"

About  this blog: This blog is part of an assignment for the paper 204: Contemporary Western Theories and Film Studies

Table of contents:

• Personal information 
• Assignment details 
• Abstract 
• Introduction 
• Evolution of Ecocriticism
• Key Concepts in Ecocriticism
• Ecocriticism in Practice: Literary Analysis
• Emerging Directions in Ecocriticism
• Challenges and Criticisms of Ecocriticism
• Conclusion 
• References 

Personal information:

• Name: Jay Maruniya 
• Batch : M.A sem. 3(2023-2025)
• Enrollment number: 5108230027
• Roll No: 12

Assignment details:

• Topic: "Ecocriticism in Literature: Evolution, Key Concepts, and Emerging Directions"
• Paper and subject code: Paper 204: Contemporary Western Theories and Film Studies (22407)
• Submitted to: smt. Sujata Binoy Gardi, Department of English, MKBU, Bhavanagar
• Date of submission:18/11/2024

Abstract:

This assignment explores the evolution, key concepts, and emerging trends within ecocriticism, examining how it has developed from a focus on wilderness and deep ecology into a complex, interdisciplinary field addressing global environmental issues and social justice. Starting with first-wave ecocriticism's emphasis on Romantic poetry and nature writing, it transitions into the second-wave’s broader focus on urban and industrial environments and the integration of cultural studies. Key theoretical shifts are discussed, including deep ecology, bioregionalism, and the critical inclusion of environmental justice, which addresses the unequal environmental impacts on marginalized communities. The assignment also considers postcolonial and global ecocriticism, highlighting how these frameworks address the legacies of colonial exploitation and the current planetary environmental crises. By integrating insights from cultural studies, environmental activism, and postcolonial theory, ecocriticism now stands as a vital framework for understanding literature’s role in shaping environmental awareness and action.

Keywords: Ecocriticism,Evolution,Anthropocentrism,Ecocentrism,Ecological Consciousness,Ecofeminism,Climate Change Literature (Cli-Fi),Global Perspectives, Environmental Issues

Introduction

Ecocriticism:

Ecocriticism is a way for people who study literature and culture to look at the world's environmental problems by connecting them to stories, art, and our surroundings. It began as a concept called “literary ecology” in the 1970s and later became known as “ecocriticism” in the 1990s. This field grew significantly, with groups like the Association for the Study of Literature and Environment (ASLE) being formed and journals dedicated to the topic starting to be published.

Ecocriticism, also referred to as "environmental criticism" or "green cultural studies," is an approach to analyzing literature that focuses on the relationship between humans and the non-human world. It critiques how literature has historically represented nature and examines our cultural constructs around it. The goal of ecocriticism is to address humanity’s destructive environmental impact, ultimately urging readers to reassess our relationship with the biosphere .

Ecocriticism isn't just about books; it includes various subjects like science, ethics, politics, and even economics when discussing environmental issues. It aims to analyze literature with a focus on the earth and nature instead of just human experiences. Some people call it “literature and the environment” or “environmental criticism.”

Over time, ecocriticism has developed in different “waves.” The first wave mostly focused on nature writing and tended to ignore political issues. The second wave looked at how human actions affect the environment and included discussions about race and gender. The third wave focuses on global issues, like climate change, and wants to include voices from around the world, not just from English-speaking countries. Today, there are many books and articles written about ecocriticism, showing its growth and importance in understanding our relationship with the environment.

Evolution of Ecocriticism

Origins and Development:

The roots of ecocriticism can be traced back to the environmental awareness that emerged during the 1960s, often marked by Rachel Carson's Silent Spring (1962). Her work catalyzed public concern about pollution and ecological degradation. This era highlighted the need for literature to address environmental issues explicitly. However, ecocriticism as an academic field only gained formal recognition in the 1990s with Cheryll Glotfelty's The Ecocriticism Reader (1996), which criticized the lack of environmental focus in literary studies at the time . The Association for the Study of Literature and Environment (ASLE) was formed in 1992, establishing a structured approach to environmental criticism in literature .

Major Phases

First-Wave Ecocriticism:

The first wave focused on nature writing and American Transcendentalism, celebrating a deep, personal connection with nature. Key figures included Thoreau, Muir, and Dillard, whose works praised the wilderness and often reflected on humanity's embeddedness within it. This "reinstatement of the real" in literature emphasized the direct representation of the environment rather than abstract theory .

Jonathan Bate, in his influential works Romantic Ecology (1991) and The Song of the Earth (2000), argued that Romantic poetry, especially Wordsworth’s, helps readers to "think fragility" by fostering an awareness of environmental vulnerability. While American ecocriticism was centered around the wilderness, British ecocriticism dealt with landscapes that often intertwined nature with social issues, particularly due to the impact of industrialization on rural settings .

Second-Wave Ecocriticism

This phase marked a shift from the celebratory tone of the first wave to a more critical engagement with how nature is constructed in literature. Scholars like Lawrence Buell and Dana Phillips encouraged a reengagement with critical theory, introducing concepts such as ecofeminism, social ecology, and environmental justice, which linked environmental concerns to broader social issues like race, class, and gender .

Second-wave ecocriticism expanded to analyze urban environments and postcolonial landscapes, recognizing the impacts of industrialization and colonization on ecosystems and communities. This wave introduced a more nuanced approach to environmental critique, acknowledging that not all forms of environmental degradation affect humanity equally, and focusing on eco-justice .

Current Phase (Third Wave or Material Ecocriticism)

The current phase, often referred to as "material ecocriticism," reflects a further evolution in ecocritical thought, emphasizing human-nature interconnections and challenging the separation between the human and non-human. Stacy Alaimo’s concept of "trans-corporeality" has been influential in this phase, emphasizing the material interchanges across human and non-human bodies and ecosystems, thus promoting a post humanist perspective that sees humans as deeply enmeshed within ecological systems .

In material ecocriticism, the idea of "slow violence," introduced by Rob Nixon, also became significant. This concept addresses how environmental degradation disproportionately impacts vulnerable communities, linking ecological harm with social injustice. This phase is characterized by interdisciplinary approaches, drawing insights from sociology, biology, and digital media to address complex ecological issues, including climate change and global capitalism’s environmental effects .

Key Concepts in Ecocriticism

Anthropocentrism vs. Ecocentrism

Anthropocentrism prioritizes human needs, often regarding nature primarily as a resource. This human-centered perspective contrasts with ecocentrism, which promotes the inherent value of all living and non-living entities in the biosphere. Deep ecology, a key influence in ecocriticism, adopts a biocentric or ecocentric viewpoint. It challenges anthropocentric views by emphasizing that humans are just one part of a broader ecological system and that all species have intrinsic worth. The philosopher Arne Naess describes this perspective as "biospherical egalitarianism," urging a fundamental shift in values to honor all life forms .

The Nature-Culture Divide

The concept of a strict nature-culture divide has historically shaped human attitudes toward the environment, often reinforcing a dualistic worldview that separates humans from the natural world. Ecocriticism challenges this binary, arguing that the division between nature and culture is a social construct that has contributed to ecological degradation. This perspective is particularly evident in ecofeminism and post-colonial ecocriticism, which highlight how hierarchical divisions, such as male/female or civilized/primitive, parallel human dominance over nature. Ecofeminist critics like Val Plum wood argue that breaking down these binaries is essential to disrupting oppressive ideologies that harm both marginalized groups and the environment .

Place and Environment

The concept of “place” in ecocriticism emphasizes the importance of setting in shaping characters, narratives, and themes. This idea can be seen in Romantic literature, where poets like Wordsworth evoke nature’s beauty while reflecting on human impact on the environment. Place-based literature explores how environments influence identity and experience, highlighting the interdependence between people and the land. Eco critics argue that a strong sense of place fosters ecological awareness, as characters’ interactions with their surroundings bring attention to the moral and ethical dimensions of environmental engagement .

Ecological Consciousness and Activism

Ecocriticism often aims to inspire ecological awareness and activism by exploring texts that critique environmental exploitation and emphasize sustainability. Scholars like Lawrence Buell have argued that literature can cultivate "ecological literacy," encouraging readers to develop a sense of responsibility toward the natural world. For example, environmental texts may expose the consequences of industrialization or depict characters who advocate for conservation. This consciousness-raising aspect of ecocriticism seeks to bridge the gap between academic analysis and practical ecological engagement .

Deep Ecology and Ecofeminism

Deep ecology and ecofeminism are significant branches within ecocritical thought. Deep ecology calls for a profound respect for all life forms and promotes a "self-realization" process where humans reconnect with the broader natural community. In contrast, ecofeminism connects environmental exploitation with the social oppression of women, arguing that patriarchal structures harm both women and nature. Ecofeminist scholars like Carolyn Merchant discuss how environmental hazards disproportionately impact marginalized communities, linking toxic sites to low-income or minority areas, often where women and children bear the brunt of environmental degradation. Ecofeminism, thus, advocates for dismantling systems of domination that exploit both the environment and vulnerable populations .

Ecocriticism in Practice: Literary Analysis

Poetry

Ecocriticism in poetry is strongly linked to Romantic traditions, particularly the works of poets like William Wordsworth. Wordsworth's poetry is often credited with fostering an appreciation of nature’s "fragility," presenting it as a source of solace and wisdom, yet vulnerable to human exploitation. Jonathan Bate’s influential work Romantic Ecology rehabilitates Romantic poets as early proponents of ecological awareness, emphasizing how poetry can prompt readers to “think fragility” by highlighting humanity's embeddedness in and vulnerability alongside the non-human world.

Eco-poetry, as developed more recently, often critiques humanity’s overreliance on technology and rationalism. Ecocritical poets such as John Clare bring an awareness of social and environmental degradation to their work, connecting the impact of industrialization with the suffering of both nature and rural communities. This approach in eco-poetry seeks not only to celebrate nature but also to prompt a rethinking of human responsibility toward the environment.

Prose and Fiction

In fiction, ecocriticism addresses environmental themes in works such as The Overstory by Richard Powers and Rachel Carson's Silent Spring. Powers' novel weaves interconnected stories of people affected by trees, urging readers to reconsider their place within larger ecological systems. Carson’s Silent Spring, often credited with sparking the modern environmental movement, provides a powerful narrative on the impact of pesticides, raising public awareness and fostering a sense of ecological accountability.

These works highlight how prose can convey complex ecological messages by merging narrative with environmental advocacy. Lawrence Buell’s notion of “ethical orientation” in literature reflects this by asserting that texts with a strong ecological focus often encourage readers to engage with environmental issues in real life.

Postcolonial Literature

Postcolonial ecocriticism explores how colonialism has historically exploited both land and people, a theme evident in works by authors like Arundhati Roy and Amitav Ghosh. Roy's The God of Small Things and Ghosh's The Hungry Tide delve into environmental issues tied to colonial legacies and the ongoing impacts of neocolonialism, especially in regions like India where natural resources have been systematically extracted and degraded. Rob Nixon’s concept of "slow violence" further illuminates these injustices, describing how environmental degradation disproportionately affects impoverished communities over time.

This strand of ecocriticism also examines how colonial ideologies justified the domination of nature and Indigenous populations, thus linking environmental justice with broader social justice. Through postcolonial ecocriticism, writers and scholars critique how environmental degradation in formerly colonized regions remains a lasting consequence of imperialist exploitation, prompting ecocritics to adopt globally inclusive perspectives on environmental justice.

Emerging Directions in Ecocriticism

Climate Change Literature (Cli-Fi): 

Cli-fi, or climate fiction, has emerged as a genre that addresses the urgent issue of climate change through storytelling. This genre often explores the potential futures shaped by current environmental policies and practices, encouraging readers to consider the implications of climate change in personal and social contexts. Cli-fi not only highlights ecological catastrophes but also emphasizes resilience, adaptation, and activism, prompting readers to reflect on and take action regarding real-world environmental issues .

Posthumanism and New Materialism:

 Ecocriticism’s engagement with posthumanism and new materialism represents a shift from human-centered perspectives. Post humanist ecocriticism, as noted by theorists like Stacy Alaimo, emphasizes “trans-corporeality,” the interconnectedness between human and non-human life, and the ongoing material exchanges across bodies and environments. This approach challenges the boundaries traditionally drawn between human and non-human entities, encouraging a holistic understanding of ecological systems that includes animals, plants, and even inanimate objects as part of a complex, interdependent network .

Global and Indigenous Perspectives:

 Ecocriticism is increasingly inclusive of Indigenous and global perspectives that emphasize sustainability and respect for the land. Indigenous narratives often highlight traditional ecological knowledge, advocating for a harmonious relationship with the environment. Global ecocriticism seeks to address the colonial legacies embedded in environmental degradation, recognizing that environmental justice is inherently tied to social justice. This direction also emphasizes Rob Nixon's concept of “slow violence,” which highlights the gradual, often unseen environmental harm inflicted on marginalized communities .

Digital Ecocriticism and Eco-Media Studies:

 With the proliferation of digital media, ecocriticism has expanded into eco-media studies, analyzing the role of digital platforms, films, and documentaries in shaping public environmental consciousness. Digital ecocriticism examines how eco-films and social media campaigns bring visibility to ecological issues, engaging wider audiences and influencing perceptions. This direction allows for a broader dissemination of ecological awareness, as environmental messages become accessible across diverse digital channels .

Challenges and Criticisms of Ecocriticism

Limitations in Addressing Complex Issues:

 Ecocriticism faces critique for its sometimes narrow focus, especially in its early stages, which tended to prioritize Western literature and nature writing. As the field broadens, it continues to grapple with its ability to adequately address the vast complexity of global environmental challenges. Critics like Timothy Clark argue that ecocriticism must remain adaptable and self-critical to respond to evolving ecological crises effectively .

Need for Inclusivity: 

Historically centered around Anglo-American literature, ecocriticism has been challenged to incorporate more diverse voices and non-Western perspectives. This shift calls for a more globally conscious approach, which acknowledges that environmental degradation disproportionately affects marginalized and colonized communities. Scholars emphasize the importance of including varied cultural narratives that address environmental justice and Indigenous ecological ethics .

Balancing Activism with Critique:

 Ecocriticism often aims to inspire activism; however, it must balance this with critical scholarly inquiry. Some argue that while ecocriticism advocates for environmental change, it should also maintain intellectual rigor, analyzing environmental texts with a critical eye rather than purely from an activist stance. This tension requires ecocritics to continually reassess their role, ensuring that their work remains both socially impactful and analytically sound .

Conclusion:

In conclusion, ecocriticism is a field that explores how literature reflects and shapes our views of the environment, evolving from its early focus on nature writing to address complex issues like climate change and environmental justice. It includes key ideas like the importance of all species, the connection between nature and culture, and the power of place. Ecocriticism applies these ideas across poetry, fiction, and postcolonial literature, and has recently expanded into new areas like climate fiction and digital media to reach wider audiences. Although it faces challenges, such as the need for more global perspectives and balancing activism with academic study, ecocriticism remains essential for understanding and inspiring action on environmental issues.

References:

Boslaugh, Sarah E.. "anthropocentrism". Encyclopedia Britannica, 11 Jan. 2016, https://www.britannica.com/topic/anthropocentrism. Accessed 5 November 2024.

Gladwin, Derek. “Ecocriticism.” Obo, 26 July 2017, www.oxfordbibliographies.com/display/document/obo-9780190221911/obo-9780190221911-0014.xml. Accessed 05 Nov. 2024. 

Lawrence Buell. “Ecocriticism: Some Emerging Trends.” Qui Parle, vol. 19, no. 2, 2011, pp. 87–115. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.5250/quiparle.19.2.0087. Accessed 5 Nov. 2024.

Malay, Michael. “Raymond Williams and Ecocriticism.” Key Words: A Journal of Cultural Materialism, no. 12, 2014, pp. 8–29. JSTOR, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26920360. Accessed 5 Nov. 2024.

Marland , Pippa. “(PDF) Ecocriticism.” Institute of Humanities and Creative Arts, University of Worcester, Uk, 19 Aug. 2019, www.researchgate.net/publication/263223901_Ecocriticism. Accessed 05 Nov. 2024. 

Word: 2652

Image: 5